RentalSource has 34 rentals in Elmira, NY. Find the perfect rental Elmira, NY Historic Maple Ave second floor furnished. Craigslist. Get Credit Score. Craigslist - Animals and Pets. Puppies, kittens, chicken coops, livestock and more in Elmira, NY. Craigslist Search, Craigslist is no longer supported. twin tiers pets - craigslist. favorite this post Apr 25 Chihuahuas (Elmira) pic map hide this posting restore restore this posting. favorite this post Apr 23 2 ball.